whydunit

A whodunit asks who did it. A whydunit asks why it happened.

A village falls sick every autumn. A salt town's product starts going damp in the barrel. Something in the world changed, and the cause is several steps upstream of the symptom.

You investigate by typing what you want to do. Order a survey, run a trial, measure something, question someone. The world tells you what you would actually observe, and nothing more.

You

Buy a sack of the rival town's salt and leave it next to ours in the warehouse for a fortnight.

The world

The rival salt is still dry and runs through your fingers. Yours has gone damp and set into a cake. Both sacks sat on the same shelf.

The cause was written down and sealed before you made this move.

How a case runs

  1. The answer is sealed first

    Before you start, the full chain of causes is fixed. Whatever experiment you invent, the world answers it the same way every time.

  2. You decide what to do

    There is no menu of options. If a person in that place and time could do it, you can try it.

  3. You get observations

    You learn what the test showed or what the witness said. Connecting the facts is your job.

  4. You write the report

    Say what is happening, what caused it, and what should be done. Then the seal comes off and you see how deep you got.

Not sure what a move looks like?

Two famous investigations are written out as whydunit sessions: Archimedes testing a king's crown without damaging it, and John Snow tracing a cholera outbreak to a single street pump.