Two investigations, replayed move by move
These are what a whydunit session looks like. The investigator says what they do. The world reports what they would observe. Down the left side is the name of each move, so you can borrow it.
Both are dramatized. The moves and findings follow the historical accounts. The wording is ours, and neither man said these lines.
Syracuse, around 250 BC. The simple case.
Archimedes and the king's crown
King Hiero gave a goldsmith a weighed amount of gold to make a wreath for a temple. The wreath came back beautiful, and the king has heard a rumour that some of the gold was swapped for silver. He asks Archimedes to find out.
- The question
- Is the wreath pure gold?
- The constraint
- It is a sacred object. It cannot be cut, scraped or melted.
- At stake
- A craftsman's life, and the king's reputation if he accuses wrongly
-
Check the obvious firstIf the cheap test settles it, you are done.
ArchimedesWeigh the wreath and compare it with the treasury's record of the gold handed over.
The worldThe weights match exactly. Whatever the goldsmith did, he returned the right weight of metal.
-
Learn the constraintAsk what you are not allowed to do before you plan.
ArchimedesMay I cut a sliver from the back, or melt down one leaf?
The worldNo. The wreath has been dedicated to the gods. It must go back to the temple unmarked.
-
Rule out the sensesA careful fraud is built to pass inspection.
ArchimedesSet it beside a piece of pure gold. Compare the colour, the shine, the sound when tapped.
The worldIt looks like gold and rings like gold. Nothing you can see or hear separates the two.
-
Turn the suspicion into a measurementWhat would have to be true if the rumour were right?
ArchimedesSilver is lighter than gold, size for size. If silver replaced some of the gold and the weight stayed the same, the wreath must be bulkier than pure gold would be. So I need its volume.
The worldThat follows. But the wreath is all leaves and twisted stems. No rule or calipers will give you its volume.
-
Build controls on both sidesOne reference for "innocent" and one for "guilty".
ArchimedesBring me a lump of pure gold and a lump of pure silver, each weighing exactly what the wreath weighs. Fill a vessel to the brim. Lower in the gold, catch the water that spills, and measure it. Refill and do the same with the silver, then with the wreath.
The worldThe gold lump spills the least water. The silver lump spills clearly more. The wreath spills more than the gold and less than the silver.
-
File the reportState the finding and what it means for the decision.
ArchimedesThe wreath takes up more room than its weight in gold, so it is not pure gold. It takes up less than its weight in silver, so it is a mixture. The goldsmith kept part of the king's gold.
The worldThe seal comes off. Your report matches the sealed answer: the wreath is gold alloyed with silver.
How true is this?
It is a legend. The earliest surviving version was written by the Roman architect Vitruvius about two centuries after Archimedes died, and the bath and the shout of "Eureka" may be decoration.
The method is also disputed. Galileo pointed out that the difference in spilled water would be very small for a modest fraud and hard to measure with a bucket. He thought Archimedes more likely hung the wreath and an equal weight of gold from a balance and lowered both into water, where the bulkier one is buoyed up more and the balance tips. The reasoning is the same either way: same weight, different volume.
Soho, London, September 1854. The harder case.
John Snow and the Broad Street pump
Cholera has broken out in Soho. In ten days more than five hundred people have died within a few streets of each other. Doctors and officials agree that cholera spreads by foul air. John Snow, a local physician, suspects it is swallowed, and that water carries it. He has no authority and no way to see the thing he is looking for.
- The question
- What is spreading the disease in this neighbourhood?
- The constraint
- No test of the day can detect cholera in water. He cannot experiment on people.
- At stake
- Lives this week, and an argument the whole medical profession thinks is settled
-
Put the cases on a mapBefore theorizing, see where the problem is and is not.
SnowGet the register of cholera deaths for the district, with addresses, and mark every one on a street map.
The worldThe registrar's office lists 83 deaths for the week ending 2 September. On the map they crowd around the corner of Broad Street and Cambridge Street and thin out with distance in every direction.
-
List every candidateIncluding the ones you do not believe.
SnowWhat is at the middle of the cluster that might explain it?
The worldA public water pump, popular because its water tastes better than the neighbouring pumps. Also overcrowded houses, cesspools under the cellars, a new sewer, and a rumour that the sewer works disturbed an old plague burial ground. Residents blame the smell.
-
Try the direct testAnd notice when it cannot answer you.
SnowDraw water from the Broad Street pump and examine it, by eye and under the microscope.
The worldIt is clear and nearly odourless. Under the microscope there are small white flecks you cannot identify. Nothing here convicts the water and nothing clears it.
-
Make the comparison countableThe direct test failed, so measure exposure instead.
SnowFor each of the 83 deaths, work out which pump was the shortest walk from the house.
The worldFor 73 of the 83, the Broad Street pump was nearest. Ten lived closer to a different pump.
-
Chase the exceptionsTen cases do not fit. Each either breaks the theory or strengthens it.
SnowVisit the households of those ten and ask where they got their water.
The worldFive families say they always sent to Broad Street because they preferred its water. Three of the dead were children who went to school near the pump. That leaves two with no known connection.
-
Find who should be sick and is notBad air reaches everyone on the street. Water reaches only those who drink it.
SnowWho lives or works in the middle of the outbreak and has been spared? Go and ask what they drink.
The worldThe workhouse in Poland Street, round the corner, holds 535 inmates and has had 5 deaths. It has its own well. The brewery on Broad Street employs more than 70 men and has lost none. The men are given beer, and the brewery also has its own well.
-
Find the case far awayOne exposure with nothing else in common.
SnowHas anyone died of cholera this week who lives nowhere near Soho?
The worldA widow in Hampstead, miles away, where there is no cholera. She liked the Broad Street water so much that a cart brought her a large bottle of it every day. She drank it and died. A niece who visited and drank the same water went home to Islington and died there.
-
File the reportRecommend something a reluctant committee can do today.
SnowI will take this to the parish Board of Guardians. The deaths follow the water from one pump, among people near and far, and skip those beside it who drink from another source. Take the handle off the Broad Street pump.
The worldThe Board is not persuaded about the theory, but it agrees to the test. The handle comes off the next day, 8 September.
What happened next
The outbreak ended, but Snow was careful about what that proved. Deaths were already falling before the handle came off, because most of the neighbourhood had fled. The removal alone could not show the pump was the cause. The map, the exceptions and the spared groups did that work.
The start of the chain was found months later by a local curate, Henry Whitehead, who had set out to disprove Snow. He traced the first case to a baby at 40 Broad Street. Her soiled linen had been rinsed into a cesspool a few feet from the pump's well, and the brickwork between them leaked.