whydunit

Case no. 2. An English river valley, early 1700s

The sickness at Harrow Vale

The briefing

The county magistrate has sent you. The parish petitioned him after the fourth year of what they call "the wasting": a sickness that returns to the lower town every year from late summer into winter. Nine people have died in four years, and the doctors sent for cannot agree.

The place

Harrow Vale is a valley town of perhaps six hundred on the river Harrow. The upper town sits on a terrace called the Rise, with the manor, the church and the better farms. The lower town, the Strand, runs along the valley floor by the river. There are two mills: the High Mill on a tributary stream above the town, and the Low Mill on the Harrow itself, downstream of the Strand. On the valley floor lies flat meadowland called the Water Meads, farmed by a few families.

What the parish priest tells you on arrival

  • The sick are almost all in the Strand. The Rise has had "one or two, hard to say."
  • It starts with a creeping, burning pain in the hands and feet, then numbness. Some have fits. In the worst cases fingers or toes blacken and are lost. Two women miscarried last autumn.
  • It is worst from about September through February, then eases.
  • It does not pass from house to house the way a fever does. A whole household may be struck while the neighbours are untouched.

Theories in circulation

  • Foul air off the Meads, which have grown marshier.
  • The new dyer's workshop in the Strand.
  • A well that a dead cat was pulled from this summer.
  • A widow on the Strand who sells remedies, and whom some are now calling worse names.

The miller at the Low Mill and the manor's steward both favour the bad-air explanation. They would like you to recommend that the Meads be drained at the parish's expense.

Your role
Investigator for the county magistrate
Your authority
You may question anyone and requisition modest help. You may not order anyone's property altered.
Your tools
A hand lens from the priest, scales, a plumb line and a mason's water level, a crude thermometer, vinegar, salt, lime and spirits. No microscope within three days' ride.
Your time
Unlimited. Stay a full year to watch a cycle if you want.

Your desk

You have just arrived in town. Where do you start?

One move at a time works best. If you are stuck, say so. When you think you have it, start your move with "My report:".

The answer to this case is sealed. It opens when you file your report.